Is Zillow Premier Agent Worth the High Cost for Agents?

I’m thrilled to sit down with Milena Traikovich, a seasoned expert in demand generation who has helped countless businesses craft powerful campaigns to attract high-quality leads. With her deep knowledge of analytics, performance optimization, and lead generation strategies, Milena offers invaluable insights for real estate professionals looking to elevate their online presence. Today, we’ll dive into her experiences with Zillow Premier Agent, exploring how this platform can impact an agent’s business, the financial considerations involved, the quality of leads it generates, and the tools that make it a standout option in a crowded market.

Can you share your perspective on what Zillow Premier Agent is and how it fits into a real estate agent’s toolkit?

Absolutely, Sophia. Zillow Premier Agent is essentially a marketing and lead generation program designed specifically for real estate agents. It connects them with potential buyers and sellers directly through Zillow’s massive platform, which has millions of monthly users. What makes it unique is how it boosts an agent’s visibility by featuring their profile on listings within targeted zip codes. It’s not just about getting leads; it’s about positioning yourself in front of a highly engaged audience. For many agents, it’s a key piece of their digital strategy because it offers both exposure and actionable leads in one package.

What initially drew you to explore Zillow Premier Agent as a tool for lead generation?

I first came across Zillow Premier Agent while working with real estate clients who were looking for ways to stand out in competitive markets. Zillow’s reputation as the go-to platform for home buyers and sellers made it impossible to ignore. What caught my attention was the promise of high-intent leads—people who are actively searching for properties or agents. I saw it as an opportunity to help agents tap into a ready-made audience without having to build that traffic from scratch. It felt like a smart investment for anyone serious about scaling their business online.

How do you think Zillow Premier Agent stands out compared to other lead generation platforms available to agents?

Zillow Premier Agent has a few distinct advantages. First, its sheer scale is unmatched—with over 200 million monthly users, the exposure is massive. Second, the ability to target specific zip codes allows agents to focus on markets they know well or want to dominate, which isn’t always as precise with other tools. Additionally, the integration with CRM systems and detailed analytics gives agents a way to track and manage leads effectively. While other platforms might offer similar features, Zillow’s combination of audience reach and targeted advertising often gives it an edge, especially for buyer-focused leads.

Let’s talk about the financial side. How do you approach budgeting for a tool like Zillow Premier Agent, given its cost can vary widely?

The cost of Zillow Premier Agent can indeed be a hurdle, ranging from $300 to over $1,000 a month depending on location and competition. My approach is to treat it as a strategic investment rather than just another expense. I advise agents to analyze their overall marketing budget and allocate funds based on expected return. For instance, if you’re in a high-value metro area, the cost might be steeper, but the potential transactions could justify it. It’s also crucial to factor in variables like zip code competition and average home prices. I always recommend starting with a clear financial plan and regularly reviewing whether the leads generated are translating into closings.

Speaking of leads, can you describe the typical quality of leads you’ve seen from Zillow Premier Agent?

The quality of leads from Zillow Premier Agent can vary, but in my experience, many are high-intent because they come from users actively engaging with listings. These are often people ready to buy or sell, which is a huge plus. However, not every lead is a slam dunk—some might be in the early stages of research or not fully committed. I’ve found that agents who succeed with these leads are those who have a strong follow-up system in place to qualify and nurture them. It’s about separating the serious clients from the tire-kickers, and that takes time and strategy.

Can you walk us through how you or the agents you’ve worked with follow up on a lead from this platform?

Sure, follow-up is critical with Zillow leads because speed matters. Typically, the process starts with an immediate response—ideally within minutes of receiving the lead—via a phone call or personalized email. The goal is to establish contact and gauge their needs. I’ve seen agents use Zillow’s CRM integration to log interactions and set reminders for follow-ups. A good approach is to ask open-ended questions about their timeline, budget, and preferences to qualify them early. From there, it’s about building rapport and offering value, like scheduling a showing or providing market insights. Consistency and personalization in communication are key to turning those leads into clients.

What are some of the standout features of Zillow Premier Agent that you’ve found most useful for agents in their daily work?

One of the features I love is the performance analytics. It gives agents hard data on how their listings and leads are performing, which helps them fine-tune their approach. The CRM integration is another big win—it streamlines lead management so nothing slips through the cracks. I also think the ability to target specific zip codes is a game-changer because it lets agents focus their efforts on areas where they can make the most impact. And honestly, the training resources and webinars Zillow offers are often underutilized but incredibly helpful for sharpening skills and staying updated on best practices.

What’s been the biggest advantage you’ve observed for agents using Zillow Premier Agent?

Hands down, it’s the increased exposure. Zillow’s platform is a juggernaut in the real estate space, and being featured as a Premier Agent puts you in front of a huge audience of potential clients. I’ve seen agents build their brand and reputation just by having their profile and listings prioritized on the site. For many, it’s not just about the leads—it’s about establishing credibility and becoming the go-to agent in their market. That kind of visibility can lead to organic referrals and long-term growth, which is invaluable.

On the flip side, what’s one of the toughest challenges agents face when using this platform?

One of the biggest challenges is the competition within the platform itself. In saturated markets, you might be one of several Premier Agents listed on the same property, which means you have to work harder to differentiate yourself. This can be frustrating, especially if you’re paying a premium for leads in a competitive zip code. I’ve also noticed that some agents struggle with the cost if they’re not closing enough deals to offset it. It requires a mindset shift to see it as a long-term play rather than an instant win, and not everyone is prepared for that.

Looking ahead, what’s your forecast for the role of platforms like Zillow Premier Agent in the future of real estate marketing?

I think platforms like Zillow Premier Agent will only become more central to real estate marketing as the industry continues to shift toward digital-first strategies. With more buyers and sellers starting their journey online, agents who leverage these tools effectively will have a significant advantage. I expect we’ll see even deeper integration with tech—think AI-driven lead scoring or more personalized advertising options. The challenge will be balancing cost with value as competition grows, but for agents who adapt and refine their approach, platforms like this will remain a cornerstone of lead generation and brand-building.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later